Shippy-ness and fanfic.
Fandom can be a freaky place sometimes. There’s always some squabble going on, or some kind of drama. And LJ seems to be the hotbed of such activity.
Anyway. There was some drama going around in the Draco/Hermione ’ship and it got me thinking. And lucky you, I’m sharing my thoughts. (Your mileage may vary.)
A lot of fanfic is shipper-based. Romance (and angst) makes the fic world go round yo. So if you’re reading a Trory fic, you feel confident in thinking that the writer is a Trory shipper. And 9 times out of 10, that’s true. Why write a romance if you don’t support the couple/relationship? Why write about two characters falling in love if you hate one of them?
So, when the winner of best D/Hr fic at one of the award sites mentioned in her LJ that she’s not a shipper (she said, “the pairing makes me shudder”) and that she doesn’t like Hermione but wrote Draco/Hermione because she wanted to write a Draco fic. It baffled me. I give her kudos for writing a pairing that is squicky for her, but why? I personally, as a writer, don’t understand it. Because I have to feel to feel for the characters I’m writing, or else, it comes out forced and sounding bad.
And then came the drama because she was disqualified from a D/Hr fic award site that’s for shippers, and voted by shippers. I can understand why she was disqualified, after declaring she dislikes Hermione. I can understand why some D/Hr shippers were weirded out and turned off by the fact she won the award and then admitted that she hates one-half of the couple. I’d be pissed off too if someone won an award for best Trory fic and then admitted to hating Tristan. Why I don’t understand is why it was such a big deal (for her and her friend who was crusading for her). If the people who run the damn awards say you’re not qualified, then they have the right to do so. There are plenty award sites, getting disqualified from one doesn’t mean anything. Hell, in the grand scheme of things, winning one of those awards doesn’t mean anything. Yes, it makes you feel good, but award sites are as much decided by ‘talent’ as they are by popularity.
The other thing I notice has to do with popularity and being a fic writer. By popularity, I don’t even mean getting hundreds of reviews at fanfiction.net or wherever, but actually having a devoted (read: psychotic) following. The height of this all is having a fanlisting for fans of your fic. I’ve noticed this happens usually in large fandoms (example: *NSYNC and Harry Potter).
Popular fan fic writers seem to be lovely targets for the rest of the fandom. Granted, sometimes the criticism is justified and sometimes such writers get a very overinflated ego/opinion of themselves. Other times, it seems like being a popular writer necessarily means that you’re a bad one. Or that you’re “selling out” and writing for the masses instead of writing quality stuff. I don’t see why there needs to be a distinction between being good and being popular.
The problem (or so I think) with being a popular writer and having rabid fangirls is that your fangirls get way too sensitive when people diss your award-winning stuff. It’s like it’s *gasp* wrong to dislike a particular fic, or think that it’s bad. And then every attack on your writing is immediately translated into attacking you as a person… and next thing you know, all hell has broken loose. And then the kerfluffle spreads all through the fandom.
So. Fandom is a freaky place. You would have thought that sharing the same love for a band/tv show/book/whatever will unite people and all that happy blah-di-blah… but instead, you sometimes get stupid things happening.